Posted by My OB said WHAT?!?.
Posted by My OB said WHAT?!?.
“Don’t Make Any Noise, It Doesn’t Help.”
“Don’t make any noise, it doesn’t help”. -Midwife to mother making straining/grunting noises during pushing.
I saw discussion of a study on the Rachel Maddow show that showed repeating a favorite curse word helped people withstand pain (arm in ice water) longer than repeating a regular, random word.
[Reply]
Jespren Reply:
December 14th, 2009 at 8:20 am (Quote)
I don’t curse, so I kept repeating ‘oh fudge’ in a quite moan during my back labor (really, really painful, contractions never bothered me pain wise), I’m usually very silent when I’m in pain, but that cramping was just so extreme it was either focus on saying something or start writhing in the birthtub. My husband said “we have to teach you some new curse words” (he apologized later).
[Reply]
Dude. Why do some people go into birth work if they hate hearing women vocalizing? I’ve never understood that.
[Reply]
Judith Reply:
December 16th, 2009 at 5:06 pm (Quote)
many sounds we make during labor are the same as during sex. people are uncomfortable to hear sexual sounds and now that all these strangers are at birth, we have to pretend birth has nothing to do with sex.
[Reply]
Michelle Potter Reply:
December 16th, 2009 at 6:07 pm (Quote)
That’s a fascinating thought. Personally, I don’t think any of the sounds I made during labor sounded like sex, but I would not be surprised if it were generally true (or even if my noises sounded sexual to someone else).
[Reply]
Someone saying that to me might then be making their own noises of pain. I HAD to scream with my fourth, who came flying out in one huge involuntary push as I squatted in front of my toilet. It was the only freaking way I could keep a handle on that particular sensation.
[Reply]
Let’s get something straight:
When *I* am pushing a baby out, I get to decide what is helping me and what isn’t, unless I am doing something that is immediately endangering myself or my baby.
When you are pushing a baby out, you can be as quiet as you want, *I* find vocalizing like a weight lifter going for the world record helps.
And oddly enough when I push like that I don’t become oxygen deprived and need a face mask, like I did during one child’s birth where the nurses got in my face and made me hold my breath…
[Reply]
The only comment my midwife made about my noises while pushing was to “keep it low”…meaning, the low-pitched moaning and humming I had been doing was helpful, and the high-pitched screech I let out at one point toward the end was not as helpful, lol.
[Reply]
I was also told to “keep it low” and I found it helped a lot.
What I don’t understand is why any provider/birth attendant would feel compelled to offer up comments that belittle mom, and offer no benefit to labor or delivery? Women need support! If vocalization is something that mom is showing a need to do, I think it would be more beneficial to redirect it in a more positive direction…like “keep your moaning low, feel it in your belly and let it rip”. Something like that. The last thing you need when you are trying to have a baby is someone tearing apart your self esteem.
[Reply]
I was told that there was no need to scream by the OB (who was a effing MAN) that was delivering me, mind you I was induced with Pitocin and was doing it natural and then I was told, “Push don’t scream your wasting your energy!”
I have a much different birth plan for my next one when we get pregnant
[Reply]
Actually, your jaw is connected to your pelvic floor, so if you can make low moans with your jaw wide open (aaaahhh)it can help open up your pelvis. I did my aaahhhs in tones, and my husband said he could tell where I was in the contraction by the note i was “singing”.
[Reply]
I moaned long, deep, and loud soon after my water broke two hours into my 7 hour labor. My midwife called it my ‘birth song’ and also called it beautiful.
[Reply]
Wren's Mama Reply:
July 13th, 2010 at 9:37 pm (Quote)
I forgot to add – I moaned with ever contraction.
[Reply]
« “…You Make Milk Like A Teenager!” Next Post
“Oh! You’re A Natural Redhead!” »


Thanks for that. I’ll go tell the black belts at the martial arts school that going “HUH!” after their moves in order to control their breathing and let out their air is actually futile.
Personally, I found screaming “GET OUT OF THERE!” during pushing helped a lot: baby was born over one tremendous push. I guess I scared him or something.
[Reply]